2026 saw several events mark the peak of that liberal pipe dream—a female Pope. The installation of Dame Sarah Mullally as the Anglican Archbishop of Canterbury followed the most scandalising statements by the Catholic Cardinal and Archbishop of Luxembourg Jean-Claude Hollerich: "I cannot imagine how a Church can continue to exist in the long term if half of the people of God suffer because they do not have access to ordained ministry… As a bishop, I have also learned that this is not just a demand of some left-leaning women's groups… When I speak with women in parishes, 90 per cent share the same opinion."
We can ignore the obvious question of how the Anglican Church will survive under female leadership. What inspires the Cardinal's words if not a deeply disordered and ironically dead, liberal culture? Regardless, on the same date as the (assumed) Anglican Archbishop's installation, Pope Leo XIV declared at St Peter's Square that the "sacred hierarchy" of male priesthood "is not a human construct, functional to the internal organisation of the Church as a social body, but a divine institution" essential to the mystical Body of Christ, rooted in apostolic succession. It would not matter if 100% of Catholic women thought otherwise. All the traditional Catholics (TradCaths) breathed a sigh of relief.
It would be facile to poke holes in the Cardinal's commonplace confusion. Rather, there remains a significant and unspoken issue within the trad bulwark communities of Catholicism: Whilst they are eager to uphold Church teaching on the sacred patriarchy in the clergy, this is far from forthcoming in the home, and yet female domination in the domestic church, the family, is just as destructive to the universal Catholic Church, to our local, national and global mission, and therefore to the wider human family.
Very few are addressing this. In passing, the American political commentator and firebrand, Nicholas J. Fuentes, has suggested that marriage under Emirati Sharia is often closer to the traditional Catholic model than Western TradCath marriages. Similarly, the imperfect machismo of the redpill manosphere provides bolder examples of an uncompromising masculinity than Matt Walsh or other Western Catholic influencers pushing domestic life as the implicit pinnacle for young men. Heaven knows our birthrates could use it, but more is needed to save Catholic civilisation in the West; we need the Faustian pursuit of arete, excellence, grand collective goals manifest through corporate networks of power and influence, to say the least. Wives are men's aides in pursuit of these things; domestic life cannot exist, let alone reach heaven, without them. Catholicism agrees with the classical world on this, making modern liberalism the anomaly, so from whence comes the TradCaths' cultural accommodation and compromise with it?
To answer that, I recently interviewed Timothy Gordon, host of the Rules for Retrogrades podcast, another edgy Catholic influencer best-known for his pro-patriarchal stand despite widespread criticism. Gordon has compiled the relevant Catholic sources in his Case for Patriarchy and the pamphlet, Catholicism vs Feminism, and most recently in his documentary, What a Woman Is. He concludes that rampant feminism is actually the essence of the Original Sin and, moreover, the leading pattern and cause of ongoing Western collapse: "A woman who was out of control—Eve—sinned by commission; her husband allowed her to be out of control and so sinned by omission, and because of this sin, by Eve and then Adam, passively and actively, we all have to die." Unsurprisingly, we agreed that the "wife guy" phenomenon in trad communities was nothing new; once called uxory (of Latin origin), it is the inordinate love or worship of women or one's wife:
"Uxory is downstream of feminism and it is not actually a response of love; it is out of fear. It is not an expression of loving anyone but oneself as the husband. Fr Chad Ripperger, in our film, discusses the cause of Adam's first sin, that sin of omission where he 'longhoused' himself by letting his wife have too much freedom. Fr Chad says that the cause of this allowance, a sinful allowance by Adam, was just looking after his own need. He did not want to be removed, as women will sometimes punitively remove a husband, from her comfort and consolation. This is what wife guys do; they are paranoid of making their wives mad by denying them a request and being furnished either a loud or a silent protest. Sometimes the silent protest by an angry pre-Christian or non-practising Christian wife is worse than the loud protest; sometimes it is the silent treatment or a silent tantrum. This is the kind of conditioning to which feminism has exposed all of Christendom. It conditions the women to act like this when they are disappointed and it conditions the men through the disappointed responses of their wives. That's how and why Christendom, en masse, is being run by women, and it is the devil's work. So, make no mistake, uxory is not excessive love of wives, it is excessive love of self, it is cowardice, standing down and a fear of displeasing a petulant wife."
Young Westerners can see that marriage threatens much more than the fury of a woman scorned. On a whim, wives might strike an alliance with the biased state; even if Catholics are not strictly allowed to divorce, this nuclear option remains readily available. What licit nuclear deterrent do men have? Too many TradCaths have silently surrendered, "protecting and providing" and no more, larping as husbands under the practical conditions of female domination. Having the final say is reduced to the obsequious affirmation of their wives' will, that slavish sycophancy of "happy wife, happy life." Little wonder that the nomadic barbarism and unreasonable defiance of Andrew Tate is so popular when civilisation is confused with subordination, when the gentleman is little more than a eunuch. This is no marriage at all and realising that is the enriched uranium from which a nuclear deterrent can emerge. Whatever the solution is, contractual or otherwise, we must at least start the conversation, which requires courage, wisdom, God-fearing men with the confidence of their convictions. Importantly, TradCaths must pull the hypocritical log from their own eyes before criticising clergy compromised by today's liberal milieu.
Are we ready for this conversation? Several trad publications (which I will not name) refused to publish the Tim Gordon interview on the grounds that he levelled too strong a critique against those he calls "Catholic soft-feminists." He argues that certain women are exercising thought leadership roles in trad circles, overextending the Virgin Mary's role as mother and wife outside the context of the Holy Family, invoking Mother Mary to bless female public intellectualism outside of religious orders, thus creating a subculture where women's voices set the tone on male-female complementarity. In practice, Catholic lay women now have large audiences on social media by which to critique and direct domesticated men in their daily lives, rendering male headship theoretical. Here is the contentious passage in question:
"Yes, the Virgin Mary was obedient to God, but the primary way She was obedient was exactly as every other married Christian woman proves her loyalty to God and fealty to God: by being an obedient wife and obeying her husband in all things. I am most interested in how She was a perfectly submissive wife to St Joseph, even though She was the greatest saint; Saint Joseph might be number two, but She is the greatest saint. Note how, even if She is greater, She had to obey him in all things because She is a woman and he was Her husband.
Some suggest that I overextend this principle of wifely obedience, but it is basically impossible to exaggerate upon it unless a proponent of patriarchy says that a Christian wife must obey her husband even into grave matters or grave sin, which is not true; this is the one place where it does not displease God for a woman to disobey her husband—if he gives her a direct order to mortal sin. We get this example directly from Mary so I am the one that is speaking scripturally and using the aid of Tradition and Magisterium. There are a lot of other pseudo-popularisers of Christian anti-feminism who are really just saying moderate-feminist things and casting them as anti-feminist simply because they are not radically feminist. Note, in Dr Carrie Gress's book The Anti-Mary Exposed, the only object of her attack is radical feminism, yet Dr Carrie Gress got a PhD, which could be the most feminist thing you can do and an instantiation of the principle I have described."
Funnily enough, I was advised to interview Dr Gress instead of Tim Gordon on this subject of the marital bond and the gender roles therein. Young Catholics have heard enough from women about what a man is; Gordon is only asking for the patriarchy to remind us What a Woman Is. Again I ask, do we have the balls for this conversation?
Yes, it is unsurprising that my own young daughters are more familiar with Catholic teaching on the natural order in both the universal and domestic church than even some cardinals; nevertheless, many TradCaths need a refresher course too. To that end, I will conclude with a most treasured story from our children's Catholic heritage. My daughters loved the Arthurian tale, The Wedding of Sir Gawain and Dame Ragnelle. The magically accursed, "loathly" and hideous Lady Ragnell ransoms and saves King Arthur by helping him solve a riddle posed by the evil blackguard Sir Gromer: What do women most desire? Sovereignty over their husbands is the correct answer. In return, Lady Ragnell demands to marry the noble Sir Gawain. On their wedding night, Gawain generously yields to his enchanted wife the choice of whether she shall be beautiful by day and ugly by night or vice versa, as the painful burden would mostly be hers. His Christian charity breaks the spell and she becomes permanently unmatched in beauty, immediately vowing joyful obedience to his will, "never to debate or contradict him," resulting in a harmonious marriage blessed with a son. Similar to Chaucer's Wife of Bath, this typically romantic fairy-tale arc of marital bliss is often perverted by ideologues as some proto-feminist fable of female empowerment. Just the opposite, it is about overcoming the fallen nature of women, as per God's words to Eve in Genesis 3:16, "your desire shall be for your husband, and he shall rule over you." Men must choose whom they will serve, God or mammon, and Catholicism grants women the choice of whom they will serve too; we can't choose our family, but women can at least choose their spouse. Note well, however, none of us is called to be self-serving or to upend this natural order.
So, in the same vein as the Cardinal's original question, I want to get the conversation started: How can Catholic marriages survive when men want to control their wives but are dominated by them? How can we expect to restore order when even the "tradwives" are an impediment to the ideas and systems required? If we truly want to overcome the liberal individualism of our age, Western Catholics must learn to think and organise corporately, to be one Body of Christ, yes, with a hierarchy of thought leaders and followers, and without partiality or confusion. Let us look to Mother Mary then, not as an individual example for the informally empowered female influencer, but in the context of the dutifully corporate Holy Family.



